
Gnocchi
Ah, gnocchi. Or, Ñocchis, as they are called in Argentina. Unfortunately, I don’t have any Italian ancestors that I’m aware of, but I do have some (indirect) family connections to Argentina, where homemade pasta is common and ñocchis are a popular meal. My grandparents, Brent Bullough and Linda Bullough, served a church mission together in Argentina in 2007-2008. They spent time in bustling Buenos Aires as well as going to the southernmost part of the continent, Rio Gallegos, which probably boasts more penguins than people. My grandfather already spoke some Spanish before they left, but my grandmother struggled with the language and never really mastered it. However, she found other ways to communicate beyond the language barrier and made several good friends during their time there.
This connection is especially personal for me because not long after they got home, I also served a volunteer church mission in Argentina, and incidentally, my husband did too, in a different part of the country. During that time, I grew to love the Argentine people, their culture, and, of course, the food, which is heavily influenced by the Italian immigrants who settled there. While there, I enjoyed plenty of fabulous homemade pasta, pizza, and yes, gnocchi. I once asked a sweet Argentine abuela how she made her delicious ñocchis, and she replied that you need to boil and peel several potatoes, then press them through a sieve so they’re dry and airy. Then with a light hand, you mix in a little flour and egg, until it just comes together. She said that the best ñocchis are made with mostly potato and very little flour/egg, so the ñocchis are very tender and fluffy. Then, you put them in boiling water and cook them just until they float, then immediately scoop them out into a dish.
Well, armed with these instructions, I thought I could easily churn out lush potato pillows when I got home. But after a couple batches of soggy, chewy gnocchi, I soon realized this was an art that would require a bit more practice with an actual recipe. So here we are. I originally got this recipe from https://www.finecooking.com/recipe/potato-gnocchi, and it’s a good one. However, I’ve made some adaptions of my own, so my recipe now looks a bit different from the original.
(Photo of me: 2009; Jeremiah: 2010) We met in college in 2012, so this experience was something we had in common.
I’ve seen several American gnocchi recipes which suggest skipping the “fork” step at the end for convenience and just leaving them in little pillows, and I’ve often done it that way. In Argentina (and Italy, of course), creating ridges with a fork is considered an essential part of the process, because those ridges help the sauce cling to the pasta, so they serve a functional, not just a decorative purpose. I remember watching kids whipping those things across a fork at factory speed, but it takes me a little longer. Basically, you put the gnocchi at the top of your palm, and then use the tines of a fork to quickly but firmly roll it down to the bottom of your palm. Then repeat with each piece. Anyway, I’ve done it both ways, and the “forked” version really are better with sauces, but you can try the “lazy” version if you prefer.

Here’s the recipe. (Adapted from https://www.finecooking.com/recipe/potato-gnocchi )
Gnocchi
2.5-3 lbs russet potatoes (about 4-5 medium)
1 1/3 cup (7 oz) semolina flour (or all-purpose flour)
2 large eggs, beaten
1 tsp salt
1/4 tsp nutmeg, optional
Prick the potatoes with a fork and cook them in the microwave for about 8 minutes or until tender, testing and rotating once around the 5-minute mark. (Cooking times may vary. I have an 1100 watt microwave.) Note: I prefer cooking the potatoes in the microwave rather than boiling, since it helps keep the potatoes nice and dry and avoids the danger of added moisture, which could make the gnocchi soggy.
Let the potatoes cool to about room temperature, then peel them, cut them in half crosswise, and pass them through a potato ricer or sieve into a large bowl.
Beat eggs with salt and nutmeg, if using, and add to the potatoes along with flour. Use your hands to gently incorporate everything, then turn it out onto a lightly floured surface until smooth, for about 1 minute. (Don’t overwork the dough or the pasta will become tough.) Set aside and cover with a tea towel. Let the dough rest for about 20-30 minutes.
Scrape clean your work surface, and lightly flour it again. Line two rimmed baking sheets with lightly floured parchment paper.
Working in pieces, grab a fist-sized handful of dough and roll into a long rope about 3/4-inch thick. Cut the rope into 1/2-inch wide pieces and transfer to prepared baking sheet. Repeat, arranging pieces in a single layer on the sheet.
To create ridges on the gnocchi, put a piece on the top of your palm, near your forefinger, then gently but firmly roll it down to the bottom of your palm using the tines of a fork. It may take a couple of tries, but once you get the hang of it, this goes pretty quickly, and it’s kind of therapeutic. Don’t worry if they aren’t perfect-looking. (You can skip this step if you prefer, but they’re not quite the same without ridges.)
Dust gnocchi in pans lightly with flour. Keep them at room temperature and use them within about 2-3 hours. Otherwise, freeze them for future use. Do not refrigerate, as they can become soggy.
Cook gnocchi in boiling water until they float, about 30-60 seconds for fresh gnocchi, and slightly longer for frozen. If cooking from frozen, work in batches a few at a time, since too many frozen gnocchi can cause the water temperature to drop and risks the pasta becoming soggy due to increased cooking time. Use a slotted spoon to remove gnocchi and transfer to a serving dish.
Serve gnocchi with a creamy sauce or a tomato-based sauce, depending on your preference. I love them with a creamy white sauce since it really allows their delicate texture and flavor to shine, but a light tomato sauce is also amazing.
This site has some good suggestions for gnocchi sauces: https://www.thespruceeats.com/classic-sauces-for-gnocchi-995929
Alternatively, you can cook gnocchi by sautéing in butter or olive oil with herbs until golden. Buen provecho!



4 Comments
Papa Bullough
Hi Brinn,
Minor corrections –
Grandma says that they served 2007-2008 and the southern location they served was Rio Gallegos (very close to Tierra del Fuego).
She was thrilled to hear about this when I read this to her.
Love you, dad 😘
Brinn
Thanks!! I’ll update that!
Sheryl Hoyt
I love gnocchi. I think I will need to take lesson from you on this one. I am a very hands on and visual learner. They look yummy
Brinn
Yes, we can do it together sometime! They’re really not as hard as they seem. The trick is to not overwork the potatoes/dough, so they stay airy.